Does anyone except me think Rumpelstiltskin got a raw deal?
I am not talking about the Mr. Gold Rumpelstiltskin of Once Upon a Time, though that is what made me starting thinking
about it.
I know he wasn't lily white, riding around on his wooden
spoon and trying to buy children, but let's think about this.
First, the king threatened to kill the miller's daughter if
she didn't spin a room full of straw into gold. Rumpelstiltskin asked her what
she'd give him to do it for her. She offered him her necklace and he accepted.
Next, night same song, second verse, except she offered her ring. Again, he
fulfilled the contract. Fair enough, though one does have to wonder what a poor
miller's daughter was doing with jewelry worth a room full of gold. I digress.
Moving on to the third night. The king did not threaten
to kill her this time. He had become enamored with her and said if she would
spin that room full of straw into gold, that he was marry her and she would
never have to spin again.
At this point could she not have said, "No, thank you, Sire.
I appreciate the offer, but I have been hanging out with a homeboy and he's expecting
me back,"—all the while thinking: You miserable scum. I wouldn't marry you
if you were the last creature to ever threaten to kill an innocent bystander. Of
course you wouldn't say that to a greedy bloodthirsty king.
But no. She wanted to be queen.
So she just waited around for Rumpelstiltskin. When she had nothing else to give
him, she promised him her first born. Time goes on. She breeds with the king.
Rumpelstiltskin shows up to collect what's his. She begs for mercy. He gives
her three days to guess his name. When she cannot, she sends someone to spy on
him until she finds out.
Then, when she tells him his name, he
gives her that baby.
I am thinking if you can fly on a
spoon and spin straw into gold, you can probably get out of Dodge with a baby.
I think we've got the wrong
villain here. What do you think?
Yes, things are not always what they seem, and he's certainly not as wicked as some. As for his incarnation in Once Upon A Time, I must confess my unbridled delight in watching good and evil battle for control of his nature. A very cool character indeed.
ReplyDeleteThe show is very thought provoking.
DeleteI agree. I believe one of our Crimson sisters did an article on villains not just being bad but bad for a reason, evoking empathy to make a villain 3 dimensional.... not her exact wording, just me paraphrasing....
ReplyDeleteGreat article!
Kay, that sounds great. I'll have to look for it. Thanks!
DeleteI love stories that mix the line between good and evil. It is one of my favorite themes to read. I love paranormal where it difficult to tell who the monsters are because the characters who are supposed to be monsters act like heros!
DeleteThe miller's daughter was a ho. Just sayin'.
ReplyDeleteAnd a sneaky passive aggressive one at that.
DeleteA good villain is written so that the reader knows and understands, perhaps even sympathizes with the character. It takes skill to do that and many writers do it well.
ReplyDeleteAnd, it even helps if the reader thinks the villain can be redeemed. ;)
Not sure if we are supposed to sympathize with Rumppy. I am going to start a campaign to clear his name. Or I would if I didn't have a book to write.
DeleteI have never really thought about this. I know there are several children's books written about what a bad deal the wolf got in the Three Little Pigs story.
ReplyDeleteIt seems it was just misunderstood.
I am going to think some more on this. Maybe Snow White had it coming.
DeleteMagic always comes with a price. It seems to me, the miller's daughter paid up in brain cells.
ReplyDeleteDHR needed to pay her a visit.
DeleteMe too, I feel that the young girl is cruel too, and Rumpelstiltskin is the good guy. He's was Shylocked. That means that he was treated unjustly. I say that he was Shylocked because Shylock, like him, dealt with injustice. He believed that the queen would keep her promise, Shylock believed that he was equal under the law, but they were both proven wrong.
ReplyDeleteI meant that he was Shylocked.
ReplyDelete